The Importance of Independent Audits

The Problem with Self-Reported Performance

Open any trading platform's website and you'll see claims like:

• "95% win rate!"
• "300% annual returns!"
• "Turn $1,000 into$10,000 in 30 days!"

The common thread? Zero independent verification.

Why Self-Reported Metrics Are Meaningless

1. Selection Bias

Platforms cherry-pick their best-performing strategies or time periods:

• Show results from bull markets only
• Hide strategies that failed
• Start the backtest at a convenient bottom

2. Overfitting

When you test 1,000 strategies, a few will look amazing just by chance:

• 95% confidence means 1 in 20 strategies will appear significant by luck
• Multiple testing problem compounds this
• Result: Strategies that worked in backtest but fail in live trading

3. Look-Ahead Bias

Using future information in historical testing:

• Technical indicators that "peek" at future prices
• Corporate earnings known in advance
• Survivorship bias (only testing stocks that survived)

4. Transaction Cost Fantasy

Ignoring or minimizing real trading costs:

• Exchange fees: 0.1-0.3% per trade
• Slippage: 0.05-0.2% per trade
• Market impact for larger orders
• Financing costs for leverage

A strategy showing 80% annual returns in backtest might be negative after realistic costs.

What Audits Actually Verify

An independent audit examines:

Code Review

• Verify no look-ahead bias in strategy logic
• Check data handling and preprocessing
• Validate technical indicator calculations
• Ensure proper walk-forward testing methodology

Performance Validation

• Recreate backtest results from scratch
• Test on out-of-sample data
• Verify transaction cost modeling
• Validate statistical significance

Risk Controls

• Confirm risk management systems function as claimed
• Test circuit breakers and kill switches
• Validate position sizing algorithms
• Verify correlation calculations

Operational Due Diligence

• Review system architecture and failover
• Check data quality and sources
• Validate monitoring and alerting
• Assess cybersecurity measures

Our Audit Process

We've engaged third-party auditors to review:

Phase 1: Methodology Verification (In Progress)

• Review of all 486 ML model configurations
• Validation of 380 trading strategy implementations
• Backtesting methodology audit
• Feature engineering review

Status: Legal review ongoing, estimated completion Q1 2026

Phase 2: Performance Validation (Pending)

• Out-of-sample testing on unseen data
• Walk-forward validation
• Monte Carlo simulation of different market regimes
• Stress testing under extreme conditions

Status: Begins after Phase 1 completion

Phase 3: Live Trading Verification (Future)

• Monitor live trading for 6-12 months
• Compare live results vs backtested expectations
• Validate execution quality
• Confirm risk management effectiveness

Status: Requires Phase 1-2 completion first

What We Won't Do Until Audit Completion

Until independent verification is complete:

❌ No Performance Fees

We won't charge profit-share or management fees. Everything remains demo/testing mode.

❌ No Guaranteed Returns

We won't make promises about specific performance levels.

❌ No Cherry-Picked Results

We won't selectively showcase our best-performing strategies while hiding others.

❌ No Marketing Hype

We won't use aggressive marketing tactics based on unverified claims.

What We Will Do

✅ Transparent Methodology

Full documentation of our approach, available publicly.

✅ Realistic Expectations

Win rates of 52-68%, not 95%. Drawdowns of 12-24%, not "never lose."

✅ Comprehensive Cost Modeling

Transaction costs of 0.1-0.5% included in all performance figures.

✅ Open Data Collection

Ongoing live trading data collection to validate backtests against reality.

The Cost of Honesty

Our approach has trade-offs:

Disadvantages:

• Slower time-to-market vs competitors
• Can't aggressively market unverified claims
• Lose customers to platforms with flashy promises
• Higher upfront audit costs

Advantages:

• Long-term credibility
• Regulatory compliance-ready
• Honest customer relationships
• Sustainable business model

We're betting that long-term trust beats short-term hype.

Red Flags to Watch For

When evaluating any trading platform, be suspicious of:

🚩 Extraordinary Claims

• Win rates >80%
• Returns >200% annually
• "Never lose" promises
• "Guaranteed profits"

🚩 Lack of Transparency

• Proprietary "secret sauce" they can't explain
• No methodology documentation
• Refusal to share backtest details
• No information on risk management

🚩 Pressure Tactics

• "Limited time offer!"
• "Only 10 spots left!"
• "You'll miss out if you don't act now!"
• Aggressive sales calls/emails

🚩 No Independent Verification

• Self-reported performance only
• No third-party audit
• No live trading track record
• Testimonials instead of data

Questions to Ask Any Platform

Before trusting a trading system with your money:

1. "Can I see the full methodology documentation?"

   • If no → Run away

2. "What are your transaction cost assumptions?"

   • If <0.2% total → Unrealistic

3. "What's your worst drawdown period?"

   • If "we never have drawdowns" → Lying

4. "Who audited your performance claims?"

   • If "we did" → Not actually audited

5. "What's your live trading track record?"

   • If "we only have backtests" → Unproven

6. "What happens if I lose money?"

   • If "that won't happen" → Massive red flag

The Future of Algorithmic Trading Regulation

We believe the industry is heading toward:

• Mandatory third-party audits for performance claims
• Standardized disclosure of risks and costs
• Stricter marketing regulations around promises
• Investor protection similar to traditional finance

We're getting ahead of this curve by implementing these standards voluntarily.

Our Commitment

We commit to:

1. No fees until audit complete - We won't charge for unverified claims
2. Full transparency - Methodology, risks, and costs openly documented
3. Realistic expectations - Honest performance ranges, not fantasy numbers
4. Continuous verification - Ongoing validation against live trading results

Conclusion

Independent audits aren't just about compliance - they're about trust.

In an industry full of scams and exaggerated claims, the platforms that survive long-term will be those that build credibility through verified performance and honest communication.

We're building for the long term.

---

Learn more about our research methodology or try our live demo.